Defining a Nuisance in your Community
If you live in a shared ownership community, you have likely heard the term “nuisance” bandied about now and then. It is an unfortunate byproduct of living in close quarters with others that at some point, another person’s conduct may impact your enjoyment of your home.
A nuisance can be summed up as a condition, activity or situation (such as loud noises or foul odors) which interfere with another person’s use or enjoyment of property. Every set of association documents I have reviewed over the last two decades contains at least a bare bones nuisance provision.
Legally speaking there are many different types of nuisances which include:
- Abatable nuisance-easily removable by reasonable means.
- Nuisance per se (aka absolute nuisance)-an interference so severe that it would create a nuisance under any circumstances.
- Anticipatory nuisance-a condition which has not yet risen to the level of a nuisance but is very likely to become one.
- Attractive nuisance-a dangerous condition that could attract children-a typical example is an unsafe lake or other body of water.
- Permanent nuisance-cannot be readily abated at reasonable expense.
- Private nuisance-this one is the most applicable in the community association setting as it impacts a person’s enjoyment of his or her property.
- Public nuisance (aka common nuisance)-is an unreasonable interference with a right common to the general public.
Practically speaking, the following conditions can be considered nuisances depending on how often they occur and the level to which they rise:
- Loud noises-radio, pets barking, screaming, etc.
- Parking-blocking in neighbors’ cars, parking on others’ property, etc.
- Failing to clean up after dogs and/or allowing dogs to run around off leash
- Domestic violence
- Overflowing waste receptacles used by owners undertaking home renovation projects
- Leaving holiday decorations up year-round
The foregoing list is certainly not all-inclusive. Nuisances in communities often result in long-ranging consequences which can include board members being recalled for failing to act, people moving out of the community and, in the most dire circumstances, violence erupting between neighbors.
Which activities have you seen in your community or a neighboring community which could constitute a nuisance? What has your board done to correct the problem?
If you have not looked at, let alone amended, the nuisance provision found in your original developer-written documents, it is time to do so. Why leave it up to a trier of fact to determine what is considered a nuisance in your community? Spell it out for swifter and easier enforcement.
Donna DiMaggio Berger
Board Certified Condominium and Planned Development Law Attorney and Shareholder, Becker
Ft. Lauderdale | bio